An Enduring Question as Solidago Turns Three
As the Solidago Institute approaches its third anniversary, one question seems to come up in our programming more than any other: How can we better attain work-life balance? This question shows up in both private conversations and large group workshops, and it’s often described as something that feels perpetually out of reach. At the heart of this question, I hear a yearning…
The desire for more work-life balance is almost always grounded in a resentment that one’s work isn’t allowing someone to fully live. The pressures of deadlines and goals feel so significant that the ability to actually enjoy life feels elusive. When this desire for ‘work-life balance’ is articulated, it’s always the result of one’s days being filled with too much work—never too much ‘life.’
It would seem then that the only solution for achieving balance is to work less and live more. Doing this, it would seem, would balance out the scale between work and life. But there is little practical application for how you can actually do this. If you’re self-employed, then you can determine the length of your workday and how many projects you take on—but this comes with its own set of pressures. If you work on a team, or in any organizational setting, the “work less and live more” directive isn’t particularly helpful.
THE LIMITATIONS OF BOUNDARIES
One solution that has been offered to help people achieve work-life balance is to embrace having boundaries. Embracing boundaries is one way that someone can protect their time away from work, so that work does not seep into one’s off-hours. If you have a traditional ‘9-5’ job, embracing boundaries might look like not answering emails after 5 pm or never bringing your work projects home.
I want to be clear—embracing boundaries is a healthy thing to do, and it’s been a practice that has saved me from becoming consumed with my work. But maintaining strict boundaries between your work and life, upholds and maintains the idea that our work and life should be imagined as competing forces.
This past summer during our Solidago Summer Studio, we engaged with Robert Poynton and his book Do Pause: You Are Not a To-Do List. Poynton offers useful language for grappling with work-life balance, and notes that the idea of ‘work-life balance’ isn’t helpful because “it sets up work and life as opposites, squabbling over their fair share of time.”
The reality is, the distinction between work and life is not as clean as we’d like to imagine. As Poynton details, any work worth doing has life to it and can energize us—and what we call life will always have work to be tended to, like daily chores and maintaining healthy relationships. If we recognize that our ‘life’ will always have types of work to be done, then the only way to actually experience a degree of balance is for our ‘work’ to have a spirit of life to it.
Work and life are not opposites. The opposite of work is rest and leisure, and the opposite of life is death. While a desire to have more life and less work is understandable, it’s built on an imagination of work as death. As Poynton so brilliantly articulated: “no amount of time off can possibly make up for ‘deathly’ work.”
DOING WORK THAT HAS MEANING
As someone who is a recovering “workaholic” (a metaphor we’ll examine more fully some other time), I believe that the impulse to protect one’s life from being dominated by too much work is a healthy one. But I believe we need to stop imagining work and life as competing forces. If ‘work-life’ balance were a basketball game that was entering the fourth quarter (or entering ‘Q4’ as we are right now), for most people I know, work is winning, and it’s not close. It’s a blowout.
The visual that comes to mind for me is this GIF of Alonzo Mourning, which captures his look of exasperation as the Miami Heat got blown out in the first game of the ‘06-07 season against the Chicago Bulls. The Heat, who had just received their championship rings earlier that night, ended up getting beat 108-66. In this metaphor, the Chicago Bulls are ‘work,’ and the Miami Heat are ‘life.’ Are you still with me?
My point here is that we’re getting crushed in our pursuit of ‘work-life’ balance.
I believe that an actual solution exists when we stop treating work and life as competing forces, and we try to inject more life into our work. For me, this looks like doing work that has meaning and is grounded in your values.
Imagine for a moment that you have an opportunity this coming week to decide how you want to spend your Friday. For this exercise, you have two options: you can leave work at noon, but you have to spend your workday alongside people who bring negative energy and pressure you to do work that is at odds with your values—or—you can work a full 8-hour day alongside people who share your values and have a desire to get creative and build meaningful work—which would you choose?
While the idea of taking off at noon sounds great—I know that my headspace going into the weekend will be awful, and I’ll be exhausted, after working with people who drain my energy. For me, this isn’t even much of a hypothetical… I can share from personal experience that I have worked 20-hour jobs that have left me infinitely more spiritually and physically exhausted than jobs where I would regularly work 50+ hours doing meaningful work. Our sense of balance is not actually a math equation.
THE QUEST TO FIND MEANING
Whenever I begin a training, there is a part of me that feels like I have driven a sort of Trojan horse into the workplace I’m engaging with. While the Solidago Institute offers trainings and workshops that help organizations have “healthier work culture,” I find myself far more interested in the lives of the people who make up these workplaces.
The aim of every Solidago program is not just to provide ‘good medicine’ that can enrich one’s workplace—we want our programs to enrich people’s lives, and in turn, their communities.
As we celebrate three years of facilitating these sorts of programs, it has become increasingly evident that helping people navigate the question of ‘work-life balance’ has been essentially baked into our mission. Our mission is to help people lead lives, create workplaces, and build communities grounded in justice and well-being. Our work is oriented towards justice and well-being, but it’s in the messy interplay of life, work, and community that our work takes root.
That is fundamentally the invitation of our programming: We want to create spaces for people to consider how they can be in community, and life and work in a way that’s grounded in justice and well-being.
A CLOSING NOTE IN MEMORY OF ANNIE DILLARD
This past month we shared reflections about three individuals who recently passed away whose work has left an indelible mark on the Solidago Institute. These pieces reflected on the dreamer Dolly Parton, the farmer Wendell Berry, and the revolutionary Gloria Steinem.
In the days following this 3-part Labor Day series, yet another intellectual hero of the Solidago Institute passed away: Annie Dillard, the Pulitzer Prize-winning writer whose deep attention to the natural world posed profound questions about wonder, faith, and what it means to be alive.
One of her most famous quotes, from her 1990 book, The Writing Life, is an idea that I think about all the time. Annie Dillard reminded us that: “How we spend our days is how we spend our lives.”
As we reflect over where we’ve come over the past three years, I’d invite you to sit with a similar idea that underscores the importance of having meaningful work: How we spend our workdays is how we spend our lives.
